We visited here for lunch with 4 adults and 1 five year old. We got there for lunch around 1pm on a weekday and had about a 5 minute wait.
My daughter got the kids grouper basket, switching out the fries for a fruit cup. (That wasn't on the menu, but I asked and she switched it with no issue.) It was a generous portion and quite tasty. It was just one big piece of fish, so if you have a child expecting sticks, be forewarned. Fortunately my daughter wasn't fazed by how it was prepared. Two of us ordered the tacos. The grouper tacos were very good. Worth going back for. The shrimp tacos were in my opinion overly spiced and greasy. They were buffalo shrimp and all I could taste was the buffalo sauce. Not to my taste. Another in my party got the grouper basket, which was also well received. Finally our anti-fish person got the pulled pork sandwich which was good, if simple. Not something she'd order again.
I'll be back for the grouper tacos & my daughter loved her meal. The rest of my companions said they'd be back, but would want to try something else on the menu.
If you own or manage The Island Cow, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.