We went based on the good reviews we had read, but this was not our experience. Our appetizer (shrimp bruschetta) bore no relationship to a bruschetta I have ever eaten. Crumbled pieces of stale bread mixed in a soup with frozen shrimp. The veal was tasteless and the only flavor on the plate was that of burned roasted potatoes and singed vegetables. The hostess who greeted us was surly and once we were seated never returned to the table to check on us or the food. She was either staring into space or snacking. The waitress was slow, brought the appetizer to the table before the bread which arrived mid-meal and, despite empty water glasses on the table, asked us if she should refill our glasses. And this place is not inexpensive! There are far better places (many with unwarranted lower ratings) in Sanibel. Try them.
If you own or manage Greenhouse Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.