We stayed at the Casa Del Mar and, inevitably, walked across the parking lot to eat here. Not a mistake we'll repeat! We ordered stuffed flounder. We were served smoked flounder - no crabmeat stuffing. Our waitress said "I must have misheard you." We later heard her tell other tables that the stuffed flounder wasn't available that night. The fish was served with sweet red cabbage. The ceasar salad dressing was sweet also. Service was slow. There are far better options available within a short drive.

The server took our order, but only came by once to check if everything was okay-after delivering the bread. Steak was well done, I ordered it rare. The service was very slow; the main meal was brought out to us by another server who didn't know anything about the salad. It was somehow lost in the kitchen. When I mentioned this to the server (when she finally came over to our table to present the check), she asked if would like the salad served now. No refund was offered, only an apology. There are plenty of other restaurants to choose from in St. Augustine.

We had a meal here while staying at Casa Del Mar as the concierge recommended it and it was very close by (across the street!) The food was good, our waiter was very attentive, so attentive in fact that he asked us if "how everything was" when we hadn't got our meal yet - the food seemd to take quite a while longer than 'normal' to arrive but when it did it was good. We were a little surprised at how much the bill was particularly when on following nights we ate at Cortesses a couple of times. We felt that perhaps this restaurant relies a little (in terms of pricing) on on the captive audience of the Casa Del Mar and this part of town where there aren't that many restaurants. Definitely wouldn't avoid this place but if you have time we preferred Cortesses for service, food and value for money.

Fiddlers Green is located next to the Casa Del Mar hotel. We ate there the 3 nights we stayed at the hotel, as it was so convenient and quite good. Beach/Ocean view from most tables. Food is good. Service is good. Much seafood and some non seafood items. Price is reasonable. We particularly enjoyed a salad that came with lettuce, tomatoes, egg, olives, potato, etc. and then could add shrimp or chicken. Was able to turn it into a full meal.
Also had a full course dinner - skewered shrimp and scallops which was good as well.

Highly recommend this place. easy parking. didn't need reservations. but might have if there on the weekend.