I have been here twice, once for pizza and once for a calzone like I saw the first time I was here. They are huge! The pizza was good, the calzone was amazing! And one of the best values at like 9 bucks. My wife and I split it and were stuffed. I have tried quite a few in my area and (maybe it's just my area) they are small and flat. This was perfect.
It is weird pulling up to a gas station for dinner and not being on some cross-country road trip. But once you are inside, it looks actually much nicer than most pizza places I have been to. Not the quickest service, but the server was working the whole place by herself which I totally understand. And by that, she was great!
We have found a definite stop anytime we go up to St. Augustine! Best gas station adjacent pizza place I have been to in a long time!
If you own or manage Carmelo's Marketplace, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.