One of the best Italian meals we've had since moving to Florida. It's a little off the beaten path, but it is well worth the trip. Our food was delicious and the service was fantastic. The owners are welcoming, friendly, genuinely nice people. We went on a Tuesday evening and did not experience the wait mentioned in the other reviews, so think about going on a weekday (even if we had the wait, the food would have been well worth it). I believe they also do lunch as another option. Fair warning, this is a very small restaurant, so if you plan on visiting on a weekend night, I would call ahead. I know we're looking forward to another visit the next time we are in St Augustine.
If you own or manage Casa Benedetto's Italian Caffe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.