The selection of seafood items are pretty good for a buffet. We got here around 7pm and was told they cannot put us in the waiting list until 7:30 pm. I guess that's when open seating starts. There was a lot of people waiting and is highly recommended that you make reservations specially if you have more than 5 in your party.
The crab legs were moist and seemed fresher compared to other seafood buffets out in the area. The service we received was excellent (as expected with Disney) and the atmosphere was great.
We spent approx $170 for four (not including tip). It was a little over our budget but was well worth it.
If you own or manage Cape May Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.