Decided to try Blackbeards this year and we were not disappointed. Had about a 45 minute wait but bartenders were more than happy to accomodate us. Our server also happened to be my husband's divemaster and she was extremely friendly and made sure we were happy with everything. Stuffed shrimp was excellent, crab legs were awesome and we left with to go containers for a midnight snack. Tables are a bit close together and dining room atmosphere is noisy, but we ate in booth in the bar area and it was very nice.
If you own or manage Blackbeards Inn, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.