Our party of 3 arrived for a birthday celebration on Halloween and we ordered a bottle of wine, a large filet , an entrée sized order of crab cakes , and two sides to split among the three of us. The restaurant was not very busy so we were hoping for a great meal and outstanding service. We received neither. We ordered the filet medium rare but it arrived medium well and they never even asked us if it was cooked correctly. The two crab cakes were very good but the portions were very small for the price . The creamed spinach and the asparagus were good but nothing exceptional. They called us the next day and asked us to rate them on a scale of 1 to 10 and they seemed surprised when we rated them a 5. Notwithstanding splitting two entrees among the three of us the cost of our evening was still $ 80 per person. When you are being charged the highest prices in Naples at the very least your steak should be cooked as ordered .
If you own or manage Shula's Steak House, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.