We went to dinner the other night and were not very satisfied with the overall experience; especially at the prices we paid. We got a great table outside with that awesome view they have. Lotta cats around although that didn't bother us; actually it was a conversation starter since we all remarked about how big they are.
It seemed like the wait staff knows they're getting that 18% included gratuity on an expensive bill so they're not trying too hard. Our waiter was nice but he barely ever came by to check on us so we were constantly flagging down other waiters to order another beverage or what have you. I ordered a drink from the menu (a Sazerac) and they had no idea what is was and when it finally came the waiter confirmed that they looked up how to make but they failed miserably.
As far as the food it was okay; the steak was good, not excellent; the swordfish had no flavor; and my tuna steak was basically six chunks of tuna tataki, not a big steak-size tuna like I was expecting. The truffled mac and cheese we ordered as a side ended up being everyone's favorite dish; which is unacceptable when paying $55 for a steak or swordfish in my opinion.
To resume, I won't be going back anytime soon. While it wasn't a bad experience by any means I expect much more when going to a restaurant with their reputation and also prices.
If you own or manage Smith & Wollensky - Miami Beach, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.