Loved it -- twice. Two visits so far and both were highlighted by exceptional food and great service.
Last visit we had short ribs, wahoo, paillard, and lamb as entrees and couldn't say which was better. Not cheap so value is issue, but you can certainly pay more elsewhere (can you say Scarpetta?)
Very sparse crowd both times so come quickly before they close (hope not).
Only downside for me is dealing with the traffic on Ocean Drive. It's a hassle getting there but the payoff in food and service is well worth it.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.