My parents have been coming to Marco Island for many years and this is one of their favorites. So we finally decided to try it ourselves and it is wonderful. We went early for their early dining special (heard about that from the folks!) and it was a great deal. Large selection of entree choices and many starter options -- besides the usual soup or salad that normally comes with the entrees. The special also included dessert and all 3 courses were delicious. The service is wonderful as well. The only fault I could find is nothing to do with the restaurant -- there were two families dining together with very young kids who were really annoying. Why do people take 2 and 3 year olds to such a nice place? The kids whined and cried and got up and ran around throughout the meal and generally spoiled the evening for everyone else in the place as it is a small restaurant. Take your kids out for a casual meal until (if ever) they can sit quietly.
If you own or manage Island Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.