I've been to Marco twice this year, and eaten at Arturo's both times. It delivers on both the food and the service. I live in Chicago, so I'm used to pretty good Italian food, and the food at Arturo's holds its own. I had the Gnocchi Nepolitano, my wife had the linguini with claims, and my in-laws both had the Red Snapper Francias. All of the meals were excellent (and the ladies also particularly liked the key lime martinis!) Although I'm not generally a fan of fried calamari, I sneaked some of my wife's appetizer, and that was also pretty good.
The service was excellent (our server was Steve) -- informative, and fast (but not "hurry up and get out" fast). The outside decor was a little cheesy -- I know it's Christmas, but the 20 foot tree and two giant stuffed white teddy bears are a little much -- but at least that ended at the front door.
The bottom line is that we'll be going back to Arturo's when we head back to Marco next year.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.