I am a lover of all things Mediterranean, however this place was ok and lacked the feel I was hoping for after seeing the name. It seems they want to be a Mediterranean restaurant but still want to serve American food also. That doesn't work for me. Our server was amazing and he tried really hard to give us that authentic feel. He was of Middle Eastern decent and was gracious enough to tell us about some customs and what not, which we are familiar with so we enjoyed him. He even brought us this 'flaming cheese' type appetizer, it was on fire. That was really cool.
The bathroom was way gross. It was a busy night, so that could be the reason. Overall I guess I would say this place is average and I expected better.
If you own or manage Athena By The Sea, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.