We have eaten either lunch or dinner here at each of our last 4 visits to Marathon. We find the food to be consistently good, service good (although always very busy when we were there) and generally a fun place to visit. It was cool and breezy when we were there on 2/15 so they had the plastic blinds down, but it did not diminish the fun time we had. We would definitely recommend it to anyone who would like a broad menu with very good food.
If you own or manage Island Fish Company, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.