The food is fresh and well prepared, although a bit pricey. The atmosphere is that of a dock-side fish market. Don't expect nice tables and cloth napkins, think picnic tables and paper towels. They are supposedly famous for the Lobster Rueben, which is very good. Only go if the weather would be perfect for a backyard cookout, because you are essentially outside the whole time here. Don't go after dark as you won't be able to enjoy much of the marina sites and activities that make this place what it is.
If you own or manage Keys Fisheries, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.