When arriving to the location, the vibe is upbeat and romantic. The many wooden walk ways give you a chance to view the huge Tarpon swimming around the property. A sandy large sitting and walking area is lit by tiki torches and on our visit, a flame thrower performer. Our party of 6 was sat fairly quickly. Most outside tables have a view of the water. Our waiter was pleasant for how busy the restaurant was. After we ordered we received no bread or crackers, which is not always offered but preferred. I ordered the Grouper with a crème lobster sauce and sautéed shrimp which was accompanied by vegetables that were raw. My fish was excessively blackened and smothered in sauce which masked the taste of the actual fish. My boyfriend ordered the tuna medium and received it cooked well done with raw vegetables as well. I tasted my niece's clam chowder which must have come from a can. The food quality was poor and not well prepared. Overall enjoyable atmosphere, but would skip dinner all together.
If you own or manage Islamorada Fish Company, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.