Ordered eggs benedict and the eggs came out with the whites running all over the place. I did not try one bite. The server never returned until my wife was done eating. He did offer me something else at that time but I declined. The did take the price off of my bill. Returned for dinner and ordered a burger medium well but it cam out medium rare. I could tell it was a good burger, just undercooked for my tastes. Once again the server never returned except to clear my plate. Never asked if everything was okay or not. Brought me the bill and I paid it without complaining.
If you own or manage Shula's 2 - Islamorada, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.