This is the best place to go in Islamorada. We wish this place were near our house; we'd be regulars. It has a very lively atmosphere, an amazing wine list, and very good food. You definitely need to make a reservation. From the outside this place looks like an old, large-scale dive bar. It is not. It is very nicely decorated with old-world hardwood throughout the inside. Service is very quick. We asked our waiter to slow things down a bit, and she totally did so. I don't think they move things so quickly to flip tables as much as they want to provide great service. We had several glasses of wine, soups, dinners, and desserts. I really can't say enough about this place. Great atmosphere, great food, great service, this is our #1 place in Islamorada. You can read my review on the Hungry Tarpon. This place deserves to be number 1 by a mile!!
If you own or manage Green Turtle Inn, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.