We've gone here a few time now, and recently purchased the summer theatre package. It's a very small and intimate theatre, with an audience of regulars. The quality of the plays and the actors has been very, very good. The atmosphere is very nice and you feel like you're stepping into a little village. It's very easy to relax before and after the show, and it's right off Duval, across from the Grand Cafe (which, btw, offers coupons for a few bottle of wine with two entrees - and the food there is very good). Highly recommended, really nice people running the show there (and quite talented!)
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.