After three visits to Key West we decided to try Santiago's Bodega after reading so many great comments here on TA. Overall we enjoyed our visit but maybe our expectations were a little too high.
We ordered a pitcher of the red Sangria. Overall it was good but Grunts on Caroline makes a MUCH better Sangria. Not very fruity tasting.
Four of our six "hot" tapas were lukewarm. We had to ask our server to slow it down on bringing food out even after she told us that she would only order two at a time. We had the Bread Pudding for dessert. Wow was it great. I would suggest ordering one and splitting it.
Service was very good and friendly. Reservations are suggested as they were very busy. We would dine here again but it's not a priority.
If you own or manage Santiago's Bodega, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.