We've always loved the pizza...but in March & June of 2012, I'd noticed a difference. I thought maybe it was just me, but then the Mrs. brought it up. It wasn't as good as previously. Still very good...just not the WOW factor we were used to. I hope that's been corrected...and will report back after our visit in December.
Another minor point. I've seen location mentioned..and reference to the distance from Duval Street. Yes, it's a little hike. Typically, you walk up Caroline Street. Duval is at the 500-600 blocks of Caroline...and you'll walk about 5 blocks to Grinnell, turn right and walk a short block to Finnegan's. It's not like walking a huge distance, and the weather's usually great with a cold beer at the end of the walk. :)
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.