We heard mixed reviews about this restaurant, so we decided to try it for ourselves. The first time we visited, the restaurant was busy. We grabbed a table on the patio and ordered some drinks and pizzas. We had margaritas and they were not good, to say the least. Like, not even drink-able. The pizza was ok. They are small, thin and cost on average $15. We decided to give it a second try last week. We went early, right when they opened at 5pm. We got a great seat on the balcony overlooking Duval Street. We ordered 2 Moscow Mules and a pizza. The make homemade ginger beer, which I was really excited to try. When the bartender made our drinks, he used a can of Ginger Beer. He explained that they were out of homemade Ginger Beer. I was disappointed and we sent the drinks back. They were not good. The pizza, again, was just ok. There are so many wonderful restaurants in Key West, I would recommend you skip this one. However, if you get a seat on the front of the balcony patio, it's great for people watching.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.
January 28, 2014
Hi Katrina. Our Pizza's range from $12 to $14. There is no pizza on the menu over $14 so the average price is actually $13 not $15. Also, our pizzas are not small, they are 12" which is larger than a personal pizza, perfect for sharing with 2-3 people. Now, about our homemade ginger beer, we do make it in small batches so we run out, it happens, we are very sorry you missed out on it. Finally about our Margaritas, we try to make them consistently good because they are good, we do have a new bartender who might still be perfecting them, we hope you mentioned to your server that you were unhappy and we hope the bartender took note. We are sorry you were disappointed with your experience with us, if you decide to come back see Lucy upstairs and she will make you the best Margaritas you have ever had, on the house.
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of TripAdvisor LLC.