Steve and Kayla have put together a great package! The master suite is everything described in the pictures - the bed is huge and comfortable, and the shower and jacuzzi tub were delightful. The tub, even for me at 6'1", was an easy stretch. Atlantis House is a little out of the way from the hustle and bustle of Duval but that was by design for us - quiet and private but close enough to not miss anything. Skip renting a car and use the bikes provided. You'll be anywhere you want in Old Key West in no time.
Most of all, they just did an excellent job of being present and providing excellent customer service while at the same time offering the perfect level of privacy. Their openness and honesty were striking. We asked Steve about taking us snorkeling one day. He turned us down because it would have been a less than optimal experience due to winds and churn. Every other boat on the island would have gladly taken our cash, I'm sure.
To top off our stay, Kayla brought us each a huge piece of her delicious key lime pie on our last day and Steve drove us to the airport. I don't know when we'll get back to Key West but when we do, we'll definitely stay at the Atlantis House.