Marrero's Guest House has had wonderul reviews, so one would expect a wonderful experience, no? We don't have many complaints... it's a very nice bed and breakfast with a lot of great amenities, but you must follow the rules.
Our first morning there, I had gone out for a run and came upon Alisa, the housekeeper, hurridly getting breakfast together. I understand rushed... but the comment of "Have at it" as she left the breakfast area left a lot to be desired.
John is great - he's not a bubbly personality, but he fulfills every request. Just follow his rules.
I was honestly a little surprised at the allowance of poolside nudity, compared to the rest of the house rules. Sorry, I can't be comfortable / frontal male nudity and female nudity, as well. Guess my Bible Belt upbringing is showing too much. Of course, all this is awkward if your 23 year old daughter is with you.
One last comment. We checked in w/ a small cooler. WeE were advised to leave it outside on the balcony which we did. We were also told the ice machine didn't make enough ice to fill it. On out departure morning, we filled the tiny rooom ice bucket twice to get some ice for the cooler before leaving. Alsia commented to my daughter: "I know what you're doing ...you're filling that damn ice chest"
Well, yes, we were gettting a small amount of ice to put in, but should we have been the recipient of profanity?
The amenities were very good at Marrero's, but the over-riding rules were a bit of a let down.

I was in Key West last weekend and stayed at Marrero's. I went with a friend that has stayed there over 30 times through out the years. It is a wonderful place and you cannot beat the location! Warm, charming and very inviting. John was a great host and we had everything we needed. I would highly recommend it to anyone and look forward to staying there again.

Denise from Chicago.

Wonderful time again in Key West for our 4th anniversary. This was our first time at Marrero's; the location and hospitality were excellent. We will be back - thanks again John & Alisa for making our stay very comfortable!

We stayed in Room 22 which was very comfortable with a small balcony. The rooms by the pool looked very inviting for a future stay.

We especially enjoyed the c/o pool and honor bar. Breakfast was fresh and delicious every morning!

We didn't see the ghost, however her presence was felt. Thanks again for letting us stay in your home. Hopefully we can meet next time and have a drink together!

Book this place now. John and his staff do it right. Beautiful property, expertly managed. No detail overlooked. Wonderful pool, perfect location close to everything. You cannot select a better place to stay than Marrero's.