My 7 friends and I just returned from five days at Alexander's, celebrating a 30th birthday - and I'm still recovering from the splendid experience we had at the guest house. This property is located in a residential area, off the beat-and-path from the rest of ultra-touristy Key West. The quiet streets and lush foliage still did not prepare us for the exotic layout, beautiful rooms, the swimming pool and hot tub, the multi-level sunning decks, the well-stocked library ... etc. etc. We had a wonderful time there.

But what sets Alexander's apart from all other guesthouse experiences I've had were the people - both the other guests (many whom were returning visitors) and the staff - especially Laura and Mike. They were courteous, they were sweet, there were INFORMED (our restaurant choices were among the finest meals I've ever had), and all were in cahoots to ensure that our trip was a unique one. And the look of euphoria on my 30-year-old friend's face every day while we were there ensured that we will will return to Alexander's again - soon, I hope!

My partner and I have just spent two weeks at Alexanders and have had the time of lives. Key West in general was absolutely perfect and Alexanders was the cheery on the cake. Staff (especially Michael) were some of the friendliest i have ever come across.
The room (number 15 - perfect for watching the pool area) was immaculate.
The happy hour is heaven.
Most importantly the atmosphere created by the staff led to people from all over the USA and us from England having a easy and enjoyable time, whether in or beside the pool.
An absolute 100% recomend and we will be going back next year.
Also i can promise you that you dont need a car whilst in Key West.

I was convinced I wanted to stay at one of the big resorts on Key West. But I compromised by agreeing to Alexander's and wow am I glad I did.

It was the perfect size. We booked room 15 on the second floor overlooking the leafy canopy and the pool. French doors opened onto a wonderful little porch. The huge bed and modern facilities were a great mix. I kept thinking we had wandered onto the set of that Ethan Allen 'Hemingway Collection' TV advert.

Breakfast daily from 8:30 to nearly 12:00 was perfect for our schedule and the food was a joy...fresh fruit, yogurt, eggs, granola, and more wonderful fresh fruit...all served pool side.

Free happy hour from 4:30 to nearly 7:00...another joy. Truthfully we didn't pay for a single drink the entire time we were on Key West. And no need to get out of the pool the wonderful staff ensures they are reading your mind and those drinks continue coming pool side.

Its definately a gay B&B, but its not cruisy. I am sure the Island House (directly across the street) is fun for some...but I would have felt uncomfortable staying there. We dropped in for a late lunch and it was fun (and did see some hot guys) but I really just wouldn't have enjoyed staying there much longer (think bathhouse meets gay B&B). Still if that is your scene...Alexander's is directly across the street and you can get a discount day pass to go and enjoy that scene...but still have the restful retreat at Alexander's.

Alexander's is also very couple friendly. My partner and I felt so welcomed and made new friends everyday over breakfast, the pool, and happy hour. While we didnt have any straight friends with us, I don't think they would have felt out of place either. Its an open and positive experience for everyone.

Now the the best part of all: the staff. WOW WOW WOW WOW. Honestly I cannot rave about the staff enough. We wanted to jet ski, to go snorkeling, to find a beach for the day, rent bikes...we didn't want to find places to eat on our own. They did it ALL...including personalized maps, phone calls, reservations...we didn't lift a finger. They got us into anywhere and onto every list. And each time we needed a recommendation their's was SPOT ON. Specifically I have to say Michael was an angel. Not to sound too gay, but he literally did anticipate our ever wish...even fullfilling some before we knew we were wishing them. Philippe too was freaking fantastic....he shared his 'secret' jet ski tour and we seriously had the time of our lives.

Bottom line...if you are gay or gay friendly and not looking for the 24/7 cruisy kind of vacation....skip right down Fleming Street to Alxander's Guesthouse and tell 'em Travis and Curtis sent you.

This is my third time at Alexander's Guest house, and it keeps blowing me away every time.

The staff Laura, Philippe and Mike are incredible, the rooms very sexy and comfy, and it is all surrounded by the quintessential Key West private garden.

Each time I've enjoyed the company of other nice guests, a well balanced mix of boys and girls, straights and not so straight, young and young at heart.

The bartender / host Michael throws one awesome happy hour! Say hello from Bill and Manuel in Miami the next time he hands you a Piña Colada!