My wife, another couple and I stayed at Sunset Key Guest Cottages for two nights while in Key West. It was the highlight of our trip in south FL. I'm a bit of a hotel snob and this place still exceeded my expectations even though it received great reviews. Located on a private island approx 5 minutes off of Key West by boat, it's a peaceful relaxing spot with easy access to the craziness of Key West. Check-in was easy at the Westin Key West. The bellman packed up our suitcases and shipped them over to the island. We hopped on the boat and headed over and there was a staff member waiting for us on the dock when we arrived. She gave us a quick tour and took us to our two bedroom ocean view cottage. Everything on the island is well maintained and the buildings are appealing to look at.

The cottage was fantastic. Right on the shore, well laid out very comfortable and high end. The bedrooms were spacious as were the porches (great spots to hang out and enjoy the ocean view). The island is very quite and relaxing at night and I found the bed very comfortable. Every evening the staff drops off some chocolate, bottled water and orange juice and in the morning they leave a picnic basket with fresh fruit and fresh baked muffins, banana bread, poppy seed bread, etc.

The staff was very attentive and friendly. We had appetizers at the bar in Latitudes (a highly recommended restaurant, though we did not eat dinner there). The atmosphere, food and bar staff were top notch. I highly recommend staying Sunset Key Guest Cottages as it's a great experience, just be prepared to lighten your wallet a bit.

Just got back from Key West and staying at the Sunset Key Cottages. This is part of the Westin Resort. You actually leave your car at the Westin Hotel on the mainland (where the boat picks you up). The Westin Hotel is in the center of everything in Key West. The cool part is that you leave the mainland to your own small island called Sunset Key. The cottages are phenomenal. All of them are near the beach and pool (and hottubs). And of course Latitudes restaurant which is also right there...which is a highly rated restaurant that can server you all three meals if you need it. You should definitely try at least dinner there once, its great. You also get complimentary muffins and bread and orange juice every morning on your porch and water in the evening. We were told they would even stock your fridge/room for you if you wanted something specific prior to arriving. I mean, how can you go wrong there? The beds were extremely comfy and the whole experience was fantastic. The boat back and forth to KW mainland was every 1/2 hour 24 /7. It drops you right off in historic KW and 1 block from all the action on Duval Street. The staff was always helpful and on top of things. I could not give this place a higher rating and Ive been to a lot of nice places.

I felt as though I was on a fantasy island...LOVED THIS PLACE...cottages were wonderful...the BEST...highly recommend...BEDS AND BEDDING WONDERFUL...eat at their restaurant at sunset...ask for outdoor seating...you will be amaze...

The accommodations are wonderful. A perfect match for the laid back Key West style. Excellent staff who see to your every need. Traveling with two kids and three adults was no problem with a two bedroom cottage. The beach area was meticulous and relaxing. A water shuttle provides transport to Key West proper and runs every 30 minutes. The island is situated far enough off shore that the revelry of Duvall St doesn't detract from the serenity of the waves splashing against the beach.