We stayed here for 4 nights in Nov 2012 for a special BD celebration. We LOVED it, so much better than staying in a hotel. We felt like guests in someone's very comfortable home. Breakfasts on the ocean-front veranda were heavenly - fresh fruits, juice, quiche, pastries, made-to-order waffles, and endless cappuccino. They serve afternoon tea too - what a treat. The staff is amazing, so helpful and pleasant. Beautiful place for a wedding (there was one the weekend we were there). The on-site restaurant was delicious. Would go back in a heartbeat.

We are always looking for that one great place to stay, that when we leave, we say, "Wow! We are coming back here soon!" La Mer and Dewey House is that place for us in Key West!

We stayed in Garden View room 408 of La Mer and it is really a Garden/Courtyard and partial beach view. Just perfect. The room is on the 2nd floor and it is just lovely. The balcony is huge and the room is perfectly sized with a nice table for 2, King sized bed, vaulted ceilings and spacious bathroom. The bed is VERY comfortable and the entire house is so quiet. It was booked solid, but we always felt like we were the only ones there.

The 2 houses have a unique "Victorian old meets modern day new" feel to them. Very tastefully decorated and cozy, yet with that great vintage feel. We met Sam (who was great!) when we first checked in and then we really didn't see many people after that. Perfect for us!

The houses sit on the quiet end of Duval Street and yet it's very easy to walk a short distance to everything. The beach was not crowded (South Beach) and while we had read about weddings blocking views and closing down the beach, we experienced none of that for our entire 5 day stay. The bar/restaurant on the beach was a great place for ocean side dinners and lunches. (Beach chairs are free for hotel guests).

It was nice to be able to access all of the Southernmost properties with our La Mer stay. We made a habit of watching the sunset from the pier at the southernmost because there was beautiful Luce music and I obstructed views! Just gorgeous!

Breakfasts at Dewey House were also well above and beyond a "continental" breakfast. There were made to order waffles, quiche, fresh fruit, cereals and juices. Extremely filling for a full breakfast. High Tea was also excellent. Nice finger sandwiches and desserts.

Truly, La Mer and Dewey House will not disappoint. The staff is exceptional and friendly and the location can not be beat. There has been some talk about the cost, but we did not run into a horrific price being quoted to us and we were able to take advantage of certain "specials" that we were told about when we booked our reservation.

Lastly, Our final night, we were lucky enough to be able to wish Sam and her Groom a wonderful wedding night and sent them a bottle of wine. She's a great asset, La Mer!! Congrats to them!

We'll be back!!

Just got back from a 6 night stay at the Dewey house with my boyfriend. We were only supposed to stay 5 but decided we didn't want to leave. The front desk was very helpful and let us keep the room we had been staying in. The room was small but very cozy and comfortable. The bathroom was huge. We had a private porch which we loved, and if we wanted to people watch we also allowed to use the front porch facing the street, and the Dewey terrace which was oceanfront. We enjoyed the breakfast that had everything you would need. I read some people complaining on here about it, but it was fruit, pastries that were delicious, cereal and bagels and breads. It was fine for us because we are light eaters in the morning. There were no grand slam meals because this is not Denny's. We had no problem putting away our own dishes since it was only a few feet from where you are sitting. It's not like they made you wash them! We spent most our time at the shores pool bar. Great staff there. We enjoyed all the facilities at the other Southernmost properties. The hammocks at the Southernmost on the beach were very relaxing and had servers ready to take your order. We really enjoyed La mer and Dewey house. We've stayed at other southernmost properties but chose this one because its more romantic and quiet. These properties are perfect, you don't even have to leave them to enjoy Key West. I haven't stayed at another hotel in Key West and I don't plan on it. You can't go wrong staying at anyone of their 3 hotels. Already planning a trip back.

Had mixed feelings about this place. Our room was beautiful and opened directly onto the beach. Their Southernmost Beach Café was only a few steps away and served delicious reasonably priced meals. It also incorporated an authentic American bar style area where many of the guests met and mingled. Also we had a problem with some lost luggage on arrival and after an initial hiccup at reception their duty manager, Sam, was exceptionally helpful in assisting us sort it out.
But…there were more negatives than I expected. Our room was pleasant, but smaller than the internet site led us to anticipate. Breakfast was basic – and that’s a generous description. Furthermore at the price being charged you certainly don’t expect to have to clear away your dishes personally!
Perhaps the biggest issue is the website leaves the impression that this property is a stand alone bed and breakfast operation. In fact quite to the contrary it is an integral part of the Southernmost hotel complex with completely shared facilities. All that you buying really is a nicer room and a small degree of seclusion which is certainly not the impression the website gives.