We made a note of this restaurant prior to our trip to Key West, based on trip advisor reviews. We tried to visit the first night we arrived, but they do not serve dinner on a Monday - worth noting!
However, we did visit the following night and loved it. It was a really cold and breezy night (coldest recorded since the 60's for the time of year apparantley!) but on arrival we were offered fleece blankets to keep warm which worked a treat. We shared the lobster mac and cheese as a starter, which was really good, and then both had fish dishes which the waiter had recommended - and we're both excellent. We were really full, but couldn't not try the whiskey soaked bread pudding - really pleased we did, it was wonderful.
We went back for a second dinner during our stay, and food again was amazing. That was a much warmer night post, and they had a band on in the bar which made it even better!
Definitely recommended, best meals that we had in Key West, very chilled and lovely place for dinner.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.