We stayed at comfort inn key west on points as well. I do not understand what previous people are complaining about. The hotel was very clean and the staff were more than helpfull. The room was pool view 1st floor. It was large clean and comfortable. The bed and pillows were just fine. The free breakfast was also quite enjoyable. The hotel is old but non stop staff washing and cleaning everywhere more than made up for the age. We would get up early each day and have breakfast drive to old key west park and walk and shop and stop for drinks. Me turning 50 years old even went parasailing which we booked through the concierge at the hotel,. They have a computer in the lobby and internet as well no charge You can also go next door to the radisson hotel to use their pool if you like. We mainly used our pool at the comfort inn. Everything was great - You can not beat key west and this hotel even if we were paying we would stay. Some people just too picky i guess. They also have chickens and roosters walking around this just adds to the charm of the hotel and location. I hope you enjoy your trip

I used my frequent stay points with Choice Hotels so I didn't pay any cash for the room. This is the only Choice Hotel property at Key West, and it was OK, but if I was paying I'd stay elsewhere. The beds and pillows weren't very comfortable and the property is dated. Location is OK, close to the beaches. Value for the points paid was terrible, 20,000 points per night. I've stayed ocean front in a very nice suite in Virginia Beach for that amount, but they have no competition in KW for Choice point stays. Staff was nice and there was a concierge in the lobby which was convenient for booking a tour. Wireless internet was at times slow, and signal varied. Next trip to Key West I'll probably stay elsewhere though.

Stayed at the Comfort Inn Key West the first week of November. It's a moderately rated property so I don't know why people expect the red carpet treatment. The hotel is older but then again, most hotels within the Choice Hotel chain are. The price was around $110.00/night plus tax which I thought was reasonable considering all the other hotels in Key West were over $180.00/night plus tax! You can easily get to Duval Street either by driving, and parking there...there is a parking lot on Simonton near the Blond Giraffe for $10.00 all day, or take the Key West Trolley...information can be obtained in the Welcome Center next door to the hotel.

The room was average, a little wear and tear, but nothing to cry about. The bathroom could have used a little more cleaning, but again....beach/ocean destination...there will be some sand/dirt.

Continental breakfast was wonderful! Waffle maker, coffee, bagels, pastries, toast, hard boiled eggs, fruit, juice, milk, cereal, etc. Plenty of tables to sit at as well.

Just another FYI, this is an outdoor entrance hotel. Your door leads directly outside...no hallways/corridors to walk down in the interior of the hotel.

I laughed when we pulled into the parking lot, as their marquee sign said "stay here, make your own waffles" -- what kind of a selling point is that? But we'd already paid for the room, so we didn't have a choice. The lobby is fine, and the staff fairly nice, but the room was dirty and outdated. The bathroom was particularly offensive, with grungy tile, and a floor that wasn't thoroughly cleaned. Water pressure was terrible. Bedspreads were frightening. There is a free continental breakfast, but the coffee is terrible. I would suggest staying somewhere else.