My husband and I stayed here the week before Christmas, based on the reviews here on TA. We were not disappointed. Booked a Junior Suite and was upgraded to a one-bedroom on the 5th floor. Staff was fantastic. Also glad I noticed the $50 room credit coupon here on TA which we put to good use at the Hot Tin Roof for breakfast (fantastic) and a couple of drinks at the Sunset Pier. Great location next to Mallory Square. Also a very short walk to El Meson de Pepe. I would have rated our stay a 5, but there were just a few issues with some dust on the lamps and the bathroom. Just couldn't justify a 5 rating, I wish I can give a 4 3/4 stars. It's been years since I've been on a Key West vacation (except for a short cruise ship stop a couple of years ago...doesn't count). But this trip reminded me just how much I enjoy this eclectic, wonderfully eccentric place. Planning on making this a frequent destination, and will definitely stay at Ocean Key again.