Plus:
Location - two blocks from Duval, but still very quiet
Grounds - lovely landscaping and pool/hot tub area
Concierge - very helpful in regards to restaurants
Services - turn down at night; two water bottles; high end soaps and shampoos

Minus:
Rooms - very pricey; need to pay closure attention to details (broken curtain; bed comfort only adequent)
Grounds - pool area should pressure cleaned on a regular basis.
Breakfast - very lukewarm; same food each day; very limited continental type breakfast

hi i stayed here in jan 2005. rooms are part of colonial houses around a beautiful pool and secluded hot tub .friendly staff excellent decor ,you wont want to leave here.

This is our second time staying here and we can't wait to go back. It is such a beautiful laid back little inn that is close to everything. The pool area is very beautiful and the whole Inn is serene. The staff is very friendly and they have a wonderful turn down service where you get two chocolates each and your own bottle of water. We will be back!

My wife and I returned from a stay at the Paradise Inn yesterday and we loved it. It was even better than the pictures. The location could not be more perfect as it is was right in the middle of everything. The rooms are very nice and large but the highlight is definitely the gardens. The rooms were exceptionally clean and the maid service always worked around our schedule, we never felt rushed. There are many great places to stay in Key West (this was our tenth visit), but this place is at the top of our list. The only negative was breakfast and its not that it was bad but it was the exact same (good baked goods, yogurt and a sparce selection of fruit) every day, which gets a little old after five days. This just gave us an excuse to go to a couple of our favorite breakfast places. I wouldn't hesitate recommending the Paradise Inn.