My wife and I ate at the Thirsty Turtle yesterday, found it (on TripAdvisor) while driving around getting our bearings. The wait was a bit more than we expected, but it is a popular spot and was only about 20 minutes. The bar staff was very friendly and gave excellent service. I took his advice and had the blackened grouper sandwich, while my wife had it fried. Both were great, and reasonably priced ~$14. But we had the conch fritters for an appetizer and they were great! Loved the spicy sauce. I'd recommend and would return there.
If you own or manage Thirsty Turtle Sea Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.