We ended up here after we walked out of Guppys (for poor service). It was just a walk of one block, and we were famished. The staff all said hello when we walked in, so that was one huge improvement over Guppys, so we found a table and sat down.
Our group of 3 had three seafood looking for good seafood and one want anything but seafood. The menu gave us many choices with quite a few specials. All at reasonable prices. The burger was good, the oysters were good, and the beer was cold. The waitress raved about their sangria, so we ordered a pitcher. She neglected to tell us that their "secret ingredient" is lots and lots of cinnamon! Since one on our group really dislikes the taste of cinnamon, it would have been good to know that. Needless to say, we did not finish the $15 pitcher of sangria.
Overall, the restaurant was fine. The scallop ceviche was very odd and not good so avoid that. The sandwiches looked good, though. The staff was very frequently and attentive.
If you own or manage Keegans Seafood Grille, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.