Six of us (and a toddler) ate here last night. Four of us got the crab bisque and all agreed it was the best we've had -- lots of crab meat in it. The baked stuffed shrimp was heavenly, tender but not overcooked and the stuffing was amazing. One had the Oysters Rockefeller and said they were the second best he'd had. The Onion Chicken was also rated excellent. Two had the sirloin steak -- one was fine, the other rather tough, but she took it home for the hubby later. The service was impeccable -- all of us served at the same time by 2 or 3 waiters, drinks refilled without asking, bread baskets kept full, etc. The only place they fell short was the salads. Caesar salad was way too dry. House salad only came with balsamic dressing. No other dressings available. So,, for a great meal, bring your own dressing and prepare for a culinary treat!!!
If you own or manage Rum Island Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.