Overall, the food was very good, but they 'spindled' a.k.a. Lost one of our orders. The rest of our party had finished their food before ours was delivered. The manager grudgingly agreed to comp for one of the dinners, but his first offer was to pay for our drinks (water and a Coke).
Don't need to go back there again in life.
If you own or manage Starfish Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.