The "Eggle" sandwiches are on perfectly cooked bagels (ask for tomato!) and the blueberry pancakes are excellent. Your eyes will tell you that you need a giant muffin, so be sure to get it grilled with butter. We return almost every day we are on vacation in the area and are always made to feel welcome to the island by the cheery staff. How could you not love a place that makes a banana and strawberry smiley face on your plate!
If you own or manage Paradise Bagels and Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.