OK, We only visit cousins here for a couple of days every year, and we have hardly scratched the surface on all the dining choices here. But, having chanced upon this modest Gulfport restaurant/bar last year, when the place our cousins had wanted to take us to was closed, it was our first choice this year for a meal out. Based on our two visits, I am ready to stand by my "best food" claim, especially for anyone with a craving for real Greek food. We honestly prefer Neptune Grill to any restaurant we have tried in Tarpon Springs. You just have to get past the unpretentious plain Greek village decor -- this is not the place for someone who values fine tablecloths and tablesettings! My memory of last year's visit was a standout domades dish, prepared the real Greek homestyle way with a lemony cream sauce. It was exactly like what I remember being prepared for us in Greece by the aunt of our Greek friend who we were traveling with. This year we started with the calamari, and I can see why a previous reviewer called these "the best calamari of my life". I actually really liked the homemade marinara sauce they were served with, with my only quibble being that I missed having the "spiders" of the calamari along with the rings. But yes, they rank up there with the best I have ever had, and probably are the best I have ever had in the USA. Other than this, my fish tacos were excellent, my wife's gyro was huge and delicious, one of my cousins ordered the California wrap (to his wife's amazement -- "He never orders a wrap!") which was far from wimpy, and probably will forever be the standard that no other wrap will meet, and my other cousins ordered the crabcake sandwich. It was a generous size, sort of falling apart, and clearly a great choice, although none of us were offered a taste. The almost crunchy, seasoned fried were declared by one cousin (the pickiest one!) to be the best ever. If we spent more time here, we would be back for the happy hour scene (margarita tuesdays?), or the live music nights, or just the food. Service on both visits was very friendly and efficient. Great place, you should try it!
If you own or manage Neptune Grill, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.