I was torn between giving this a three or a four rating. There's a lot of good about this place--2 for 1 drinks every day, excellent location right on the beach at the Wyndham, and always had great service. The food was consistently just good. Standouts are the hot crab dip and the conch fritters. Everything else I had was just fine, not necessarily anything special but it is a tiki restaurant. I was here with a lot of family for a wedding, and this was definitely our afternoon/evening hangout.
The views, relaxed atmosphere and great service definitely make it a good option if you're staying at the Wyndham or nearby. Lastly, prices were really excellent, especially for the amount of food you get.
If you own or manage Pincher's Crab Shack Tiki Bar, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.