By "home" we mean this is the kind of place you would frequent back home, for the good food and value. Nothing pretentious about the place, but it has a nice laidback feeling. We had hogfish and mahi mahi and it was very good, served by a friendly waitress who told us the key lime pie is "awesome" so we tried it - and it really was good! Within walking distance of two hotels.
If you own or manage Captain's Restaurant and seafood market, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.