My in-laws live in town, so I visit several times a year, usually going to Rotelli's at least a few times per year. My teens love it, too.
We have the best luck with pasta and pizza (including calzone) dishes. A few of the "non-Italian-ish" specials over the years have been a mixed bag. I like their calzone and "Rotelli's Pasta" (? their 'signature dish' according to their menu) in particular.
The restaurant is casual in decor, so probably not a place to go for a "fine dining" meal. I especially enjoy sitting in the tables on the main street (Atlantic Avenue?) in downtown Delray Beach.
If you own or manage Rotelli, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.