Went only once at the end of vacation this year, and wish we had discovered it earlier in the week--would have been there at least twice. The lamb gyro was out of this world, stuffed with a huge amount of tender, tasty lamb, fresh lettuce, tomato and onions. I ordered a side of fries, and they were perfect, dusted with seasoned salt. The spinach pie, apparently was just delish. Watch out for ordering falafel...they are pre-made and sitting in a warming pan. That makes no sense, because I've made them homemade and they fry up in a flash.
One problem: I was charged for a combo, and that is not what I ordered. It was a buck overcharged, and we didn't want to argue on last day of vacation. Just watch your bill closely here. The same person who tallied our bill was also complaining loudly about the boss yelling at her, etc., so that is the atmosphere. Also, just know, this is probably better for a lunch...you order at the counter, kind of like Panera Bread.
If you own or manage Athens Gyros, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.