My husband and I went to this restaurant for a third time to try to give it one more chance. Unfortunately, it was even worse than our other visits, and we didn’t think that would be possible!! For an appetizer, we ordered the stuffed mushrooms. They were two mushrooms stuffed with imitation crabmeat. Before ordering, we were told by the waitress it was real crabmeat and they were cooked in the oven. Totally false!! The mushrooms were cooked stovetop and the fake crap was put into them, uncooked!!! Then, for dinner I ordered the shrimp and scallops a la david. When they came out, there was absolutely no flavor at all and no sauce, including no mushrooms (which are stated on the menu)!!! And to top it off, the rice was even bland and overcooked, like it was from at least the day before. The whole experience was horrible and we will never be back!! They should be absolutely ashamed to try to call them “fine dining”!!!
If you own or manage Island Hotel Bed & Breakfast, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.