We visited on a Saturday for lunch with 5 adults, a 7 year old and a 4 year old. The place was busy that day, but the service was good. No one in our group ordered the same meal, but all the comments were the same -- nice fresh, tasty food, with generous meat portions on all the sandwiches. Crab cake was the best my NYC sister has tasted! My Rueben sandwich was extra good, and the rest of our family had excellent comments too. The only "downside" is the place is on the smaller side, so seating is at a premium and it's also next to a very popular seafood restaurant -- Big Fish -- so the parking is limited; if the garden center next store is closed, it opens up more parking. The menu lists Happy Hour specials like $5 hamburgers, sandwiches and other nightly specials. Convenient location on Route 1.
If you own or manage Arena's Deli, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.