I can't imagine there are many restaurants in Rehoboth better than this one. We sat at the bar, ate a couple dozen oysters and a couple appetizers, several cocktails and beers. We spent about three hours here, and it was just a great experience. Note that not only were we here off season, we were here the Saturday before Christmas, which I imagine is about the quietest time of the year. Their cocktail list is fun with a great top-shelf selection; their beer list is strong, though they need a few more lower-ABV beers; and the wine list is more than sufficient. The oysters were also top-notch, with a great selection (about eight options the day we were there). Highly recommend this place, though I bet in the summer it's a zoo, it's that good.
If you own or manage Henlopen City Oyster House, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.