We have been going to the Buttery (aka The Butterball) for over a decade. We have had some fantastic meals over the years although the atmosphere can be a bit stuffy at times.
On New Year's Evening we had dinner with two other couples and it was an utter disappointment......and a costly one. Over the years it seems as though the service has been spotty but our recent waitress (Linda) took our breath away.
Without going into too many details the night may have been a confluence of the stars. Not only was the food preparation off (stuffed pork loin= cold, overcooked, and dry with yellow snapper = raw in the middle (not rare)) but the service was horrible.
I hope the Buttery can right the ship. They seem to be having issues with service in the past couple of years whether it be behind the bar or in the wait staff.
If you own or manage The Buttery, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.