A great little hole in the wall, with a combination of what Americans expect Mexican food to look like (burritos, enchiladas, etc.) which we didn't try, and a good selection of entrees. The salsa is indeed very fresh and good, and the shrimp dishes are great - large, perfectly cooked shrimp in flavorful sauces. Very polite server, and nice atmosphere (not a romantic "date" place by any stretch of the imagination, but quirky for a strip mall Mexican place). It is not cheap, but certainly fairly priced for what you get. We'll certainly be back, probably often.
The negative reviewer sounds like someone I would never want to meet in my restaurant. Beyond being obviously high maintenance, comparing authentic Mexican food to On the Border shows little appreciation for this cuisine. "I had an enchilada dinner; my husband had the burrito dinner." Ummm...yeah, those were adventurous picks.
If you own or manage Fiesta 5 Demayo Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.