Lived in the area my whole life. Have been to L&J's more times than I can count. Although their shirts are very popular, the food is just okay and kinda pricey. Seems to be a perpetual favorite of the early bird special crowd. Lots of fried heavy fish.... it's fresh, but you could do a lot better by driving up/down route 1 and stopping elsewhere.
If you own or manage Lenny & Joe's Fish Tale, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.