I've eaten here before and have always had a good experience. Open Wed-Sunday, they offer good value for the budget. Entrees run from $11-25, nice selection of appetizers, desserts. Ambience is very nice. My dinner was chicken with an apple/raisin stuffing, other person had meatloaf. The meatloaf is a bit spicy as it has chorizo sausage in it. Definite kick! If you like spicy, you'll love it. Roasted potatoes and other vegetables come with entree. Appetizers were onion soup (good) and an excellent shellfish chowder. We shared a dessert, sour cream coffee cake (I think it would have tasted better if it were warmed up).
There is a guitar player on Sat nights who is very good. It is a bit out of the way but is definitely worth it, not far from Mystic Seaport in case you're there for the day. They also have an inn so you can stay there. Check their website as they do offer some overnight deals including dinner/breakfast which are very competitive with local motels (and a LOT nicer!)
If you own or manage Restaurant at Stonecroft, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.