The pizza here is usually good, not eye-poppingly good but consistent. If you're dining in stay away from non-traditional Italian dishes, Prime Rib is definitely NOT their specialty. If you're calling in for take out make the person taking your order REPEAT it to you before hanging up and when you go to pick it up CHECK IT before leaving!
3 times in the last year or so I have received the wrong pizza and just last month I got there to pick up my order and the girl behind the counter reached into her apron, pulled out my order, gave me a dumb grin and said "Oops, sorry, I forgot to put it in."
That was the last pass I'll give them...too many "Oops", From now on I give my business to Village Pizza in Moodus.
If you own or manage Haddam Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.