Two years ago we discovered Costello's Clam Shack, the clams were good and the fish sandwich exceptional. The menu describes their fish sandwich as a "Plum Center Cut of North Atlantic Cod, Batter Fried and served on a toasted roll". The sandwich two years ago was just that, a plump, very, very fresh, large piece of Cod, cooked to perfection. It was served on a Kaiser Roll and was such a large portion of fish it stuck out from the edges of the roll, a very hearty sandwich indeed. I waited two years to go back to Costello's to have another of those magnificent fish sandwiches. To my dismay what I was served this time was a triangular, commercially purchased, thick battered, frozen fish filet which did not even cover the hamburger bun it was served on (no more kaiser rolls). I asked if there were different types of fish sandwiches to choose from, figuring maybe I had made a mistake, No, that was the only fish sandwich they offered. How disappointing.
If you own or manage Costello's Clam Shack, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.